A delightful, consistent experience that imo doesn't do anything crazy but makes for a nice time. I think the ocean parts are not that great visually but the overworld sections look quite nice. And there's lots of great mechanics here.

Easy 10/10 level. Everything is super polished and well made, I have 0 complaints.

Nothing really outstanding in this level, but I don't have any major issues with it. Theming is executed great too (6.5)

I adore everything under the sea in this level, the scenery is so pretty and peaceful, and the atmosphere works with it really well. The goofy pirate bossfight meshes poorly with the rest of the level, and feels like a jarring shift in tone.